Login Register

No-go areas faced by disabled people on shopping trips to Penzance

By The Cornishman  |  Posted: January 17, 2013

  • Theo Blackmore negotiates a raised pavement. www.thisiscornwall.co.uk/buyaphoto

  • Theo Blackmore on the streets of Penzance. www.thisiscornwall.co.uk/buyaphoto

  • Theo Blackmore on the streets of Penzance. PZPM20130112A-007_C.JPG

  • Theo Blackmore on the streets of Penzance. PZPM20130112A-005_C.JPG

  • The steepness of Jennings Street Penzance makes it difficult to negotiate for wheelchair users. PZPM20130112A-004_C.JPG

  • Theo Blackmore (left) chats with fellow mobility scooter user Andy Cowie on the streets of Penzance. PZPM20130112A-003_C.JPG

  • Theo Blackmore (left) chats with fellow mobility scooter user Andy Cowie on the streets of Penzance. PZPM20130112A-002_C.JPG

  • Theo Blackmore on the streets of Penzance. PZPM20130112A-001_C.JPG

Comments (2)

VISITING the town centre becomes an almost military operation for some disabled people.

Routes are planned and shops that need visiting are plotted before even leaving the house.

Theo Blackmore never brings his wheelchair into the town centre. The strategic partnership manager for Disability Cornwall said there were a number of obstacles posed to disabled people when trying to negotiate Penzance high street.

"There is the steepness of hills to contend with, access problems because of temporary works and inaccessible shops and businesses," said the 46-year-old from Paul.

Related content

"Many shops have steps."

Meeting Mr Blackmore, who has multiple sclerosis, at the bottom of Causewayhead, we decided to travel around the town to see how he would get on negotiating the high kerbs, narrow pavements and steep, cobbled walkways.

Much of Chapel Street would be a no-go area for someone in a wheelchair unless, like Theo, they are lucky enough to have a mobility scooter. There is then the choice of using the road but this still leaves the driver having to find where the kerb drops down so they can get back onto the pavement and into shops.

Heading down Market Jew Street, we stop to chat to another local man using a scooter to get around.

"I never bring my wheelchair into Penzance town centre, I have tried but I am not strong enough in the arms to get up and down Market Jew Street," said Andy Cowie.

"I can't get in lots of shops and even the ones I can get in, some of them have narrow aisles that I can't get around."

Leaving him to get on with his shopping, we travel towards the railway station where a line of scaffolding has been put up as works are carried out to refurbish the site.

"I can't get through the walkway in the scaffolding," said Mr Blackmore.

"This happens all the time, you plan your route then you come into town and find obstacles."

Some of the hazards posing difficulties for wheelchair users and also those using crutches and walking sticks, are just part and parcel of the fabric of a traditional Cornish market town. Cobbles and narrow kerbs can be found in many areas and Mr Blackmore said he wasn't sure what the answer to the access question was.

But he did show me an example of where a business had adapted for its disabled customers. The Post Office used to have a step outside the entrance but the company has managed to incorporate a permanent stone ramp giving far easier access.

It is important not just for disabled people but also for businesses to get access right.

"The spending power of disabled people in the UK is £80 billion," said Mr Blackmore.

"One in four families have someone who is disabled. There is a lot of money out there that these people cannot spend in these shops. They will instead go to out-of-town shopping areas and that money is all going out of the county instead of staying locally."

It isn't just problems accessing the high street that can give disabled people cause for concern.

Mr Blackmore believes it is difficult to find accommodation providers in Penzance which are completely wheelchair accessible.

"Twenty-five thousand disabled visitors come to Cornwall every year and they will come with families and friends," he said.

"If you can find a hotel in Penzance they could use if they are in a wheelchair, I would be surprised."

From his own experiences, Mr Blackmore added that he advised disabled visitors to carefully research their accommodation in Penzance. If they failed to find suitable accommodation in the town, fully accessible rooms may be available at Hayle Travelodge, he added.

Arnaud Ruetsch, chairman of the Penzance District Tourism Association, said wheelchair access was an issue but so far no solution had been found.

"Many guest houses are old and have lots of large granite stairs and unfortunately there is nothing we can do," he said.

"If we can master wheelchair access as a town, it is a huge market. It is not that we do not want it, just that we haven't found a solution yet."

A spokesman for Disability Rights UK, an organisation which fights for equality for disabled people, said it was up to individual businesses to ensure they adhered to the Equality Act, legislation that includes the former Disability Discrimination Act.

"Every business has to consider how to make sure it is not discriminating against disabled customers," the spokesman said, adding that the duty is on each individual business rather than the local authority.

"It does vary. For example, if you had a small tourist shop with a second floor you wouldn't necessarily have to have a lift put in but it might be reasonable to have a member of staff bring items from upstairs.

"They have to adapt to the need, within the restraint of the business."

Disability Cornwall can assist with an access audit and help to find solutions for disability access issues.

It has also launched a directory of accessible venues and services and encourages comments. Visit www.disabilitycornwall.org.uk

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters

2 comments

  • twofeetofsnow  |  April 15 2013, 6:04PM

    @jimjams2011... I hope you never find yourself in a wheelchair, you might spend a long time weeping and a short time losing the callous attitude. Do you think Causeway Head was always block paved? Times change and if Penzance fails to move with them, Penzance will fail faster than it is already.

    Rate 0
    Report
  • twofeetofsnow  |  April 15 2013, 5:54PM

    I used to wheel myself around Penzance before the pavements were lowered at crossings and a few other points, cobbles and steps are still a problem, banks make little access for mobility scooters and the weight of wandering people who don't give a damn make almost every trip to town a nightmare. Having supermarkets outside town is a slap in the face to disabled people who don't drive or walk easily, shopper buses don't stop anywhere near enough to walk to or carry your shopping home from, taxis become the safest option and all of them are brilliant, the difficult part is the cost, a vist to the dentist or doctor can be £10 before even being seen. Years ago a town councillor appeared in the Cornishman stating he had been round the town in a wheelchair without a problem, they forgot to mention his assistant who pushed him all day. Buses can accept wheelchairs at the bus station, not quite the same as the local bus stop, in total I would give Penzance 3 out of 10 for disability access, most of that is for the kind people who think nothing of helping when they see someone struggling.

    Rate 0
    Report
  • 1newlyn  |  January 19 2013, 3:39AM

    It,s Penzance and this is part of it,s character. I did notice two mob carts blocking the pavment in the associated pictures ! Some of these people do not realise it is a privilge to have one of these scooters yet they behave in some case like boy racers with no regards to the pedestrian.

    Rate   4
    Report
  • lulu289  |  January 18 2013, 8:42PM

    I totally sympathise, even more so since having to negotiate my way around the town and shops with a pushchair. I think a few things could be done to help improve the current situation but I would be hesitant about any work that was going to change some of Penzance's charm and original features.

    Rate   4
    Report
  • jimjams2011  |  January 17 2013, 11:43PM

    Its a traditional cornish town. RE: andy cowies complaint about going up Market Jew Street, you can't change hills. In Yorkshire a town had to have its cobbles removed due to issues like this.

    Rate   5
    Report

      YOUR COMMENTS AWAITING MODERATION

       
       

      MORE NEWS HEADLINES

       
       

      Poll

      Do you think it is hard for disabled people to get around Penzance high street?

       

      MOST POPULAR