Login Register

New hospital idea by prospective Tory MP

By The Cornishman  |  Posted: March 06, 2014

Derek Thomas at the St Clare site which he believes would be ideal for a new hospital.

Comments (4)

BUILD a completely new hospital at St Clare is the suggestion of a prospective MP as talks about the future of the key Penzance site begin.

A first consultation event took place last week to consider possible future development on the site which includes the Cornwall Council One-Stop offices, the former council nursery and greenhouses and the currently unused all-weather pitch.

The site is considered suitable for a mix of uses, including residential, office, leisure, community, and health facilities and, while the Grade II Listed York House must be retained, piecemeal additions are not necessarily considered not worthy of retention.

Derek Thomas, the Conservative prospective parliamentary candidate for the St Ives constituency, says the site provides an ideal opportunity to consider a new hospital, including a critical illness diagnostic centre and post- operative recovery unit.

"There is clearly a pressing need for a new diagnostic and recovery centre locally," he said.

"I can fully accept that you may have to travel to receive specialist care for certain conditions but at the moment too many people are having to travel and to wait longer than they should to be diagnosed and patients should be near their families as they recover.

"Medical care is advancing and our population increasing. We must grapple with how we deliver healthcare in an ambitious and radical way.

"I would like to see a new West Cornwall Hospital that does not have the restraints of an aged, landlocked building."

Mr Thomas has asked for an urgent meeting with the Secretary of State for Health on the matter and is contacting local health professionals, the Hospitals Trust and the council to begin an exploratory dialogue.

He suggests that a new build at St Clare could also include services and in-patient facilities formerly provided at Poltair and doctors' surgeries while it would free up the current hospital site for housing at a more suitable site close to the town centre.

"Before this site goes forever, I want to make sure that we have looked carefully at the possibility of moving the hospital," he added.

"Cornwall Council is open-minded to it being used for whatever works for the local area. I recognise that this idea presents a huge challenge not least because of the sheer cost of such a scheme but if we get this right it will improve services and facilities for decades to come."

Read more from The Cornishman

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters


  • nickthompson  |  March 08 2014, 9:58AM

    Strange view Mr Thompson, when the party you represent is shutting Hospitals down nationwide!

    |   1
  • westwelsh  |  March 06 2014, 8:20PM

    Tories are bad for Cornwall, support Mebyon Kernow for a properly managed CORNISH health service!!

    |   -15
  • TheodoreV  |  March 06 2014, 12:23PM

    Excuse me! Not enough money to staff and maintain the existing hospital services or to keep Poltair functioning, but enough to build, equip and man a brand new one???? Something, somewhere doesn't add up.

    |   4
  • twofeetofsnow  |  March 06 2014, 10:22AM

    A nice idea but the siting of the cemetery and the junior school makes emergency access a problem, perhaps if a new centralised hospital that included the fire station and an ambulance station was built on the site, with a dedicated access route onto the by-pass that avoided the bottle neck at the cemetery entrance, Penzance health care might finally be dragged into the 21st Century. The elderly and disabled people who have to travel for hours to Treliske for a ten minute appointment deserve better localised care.

    |   1